Reunited at the funeral of hometown hero Chris Hayden, the friends find tensions escalating rapidly as their darkest secrets are revealed. Jeremy (David A.R. White-"Mercy Streets"), struggling with his calling as a former youth pastor, is caught in an awkward love triangle between his newfiancée and his old flame Sherry (Tracey Melchoir,"Bold and Beautiful") Asthe embers of the past relationship reignite, Jeremy's fiancée Rachel (Stacey Keanan-"Step by Step"), who is determined to solidify their relationship, demands he affirm his commitment to her.
Meanwhile, Gary (John Schneider-"Dukes of Hazzard", "Smallville" questionseveryone's beliefs as this close-knit group of friends disputes world views, lifestyles, and personal passions. Pastor Wexler (Reginald Vel Johnson-"Die Hard", "Family Matters") encourages them not to give up but to follow the truth that Chris Hayden lived.