"Sometimes the best gifts are those that were once lost--"
"and are rediscovered."
Lucy and Charlie's relationship has been on the rocks. With the newfound confidence that comes with her nursing career, Lucy realizes she doesn't need to put up with Charlie's nonsense anymore. But just as she's about to call it quits, a lost-looking teenager crosses her path. Seeing that the girl is sick and alone, Lucy takes her in despite Charlie's protests. This could be what makes or breaks their frayed relationship, but right now, Lucy's main concern is getting the girl's real story and helping her--if she'll let Lucy in.
Betty is a busy woman, but with a grown son embarking on his own life, and an ex-husband starting a new family, she realizes she's been too busy to find a life partner of her own. That is until Santa bears an unexpected gift at the Rotary Club's Christmas party: himself. Has the holiday cheer gone to her head, or is she really attracted to a struggling magazine writer who plays dress-up? Betty can tug on Santa's beard all she wants, but unless she believes that goodness comes in different packages, she risks being passed over by Santa this Christmas.