Chapter One
THE
PORCUPINE'S
DILEMMA
To make a start where we are, we must recognize that our
world is not normal, but only usual at present.
Dallas Willard
Community is the place where the person you least want to
live with always lives.
Henri Nouwen
In certain stores you will find a section of merchandise available at
greatly reduced prices. The tip-off is a particular tag you will see on
all the items in that area. Each tag carries the same words: as is.
This is a euphemistic way of saying, "These are damaged goods."
Sometimes they're called slightly irregular. The store is issuing you fair
warning: "This is the department of Something's-Gone-Wrong. You're
going to find a flaw here: a stain that won't come out; a zipper that
won't zip; a button that won't butt-there will be a problem. These
items are not normal.
"We're not going to tell you where the flaw is. You'll have to look
for it.
"But we know it's there. So when you find it-and you will find
it-don't come whining and sniveling to us. Because there is a fundamental
rule when dealing with merchandise in this corner of the store:
No returns. No refunds. No exchanges. If you were looking for perfection,
you walked down the wrong aisle. You have received fair warning.
If you want this item, there is only one way to obtain it. You must take
it as is."
When you deal with human beings, you have come to the "as-is" corner
of the universe. Think for a moment about someone in your life. Maybe
the person you know best, love most. That person is slightly irregular.
That person comes with a little tag: There's a flaw here. A streak of
deception, a cruel tongue, a passive spirit, an out-of-control temper. I'm not
going to tell you where it is, but it's there. So when you find it-and you will
find it-don't be surprised. If you want to enter a relationship with this
model, there is only one way. "As is."
If you were looking for perfection, you've walked down the wrong
aisle.
We are tempted to live under the illusion that somewhere out there
are people who are normal. In the movie As Good As It Gets, Helen
Hunt is wracked by ambivalence toward Jack Nicholson. He is kind
and generous to her and her sick son, but he is also agoraphobic,
obsessive-compulsive, and terminally offensive: If rudeness were measured
in square miles, he'd be Texas. In desperation, Helen finally cries
to her mother: I just want a normal boyfriend.
Oh, her mother responds in empathy, everybody wants one of those.
There's no such thing, dear.
When we enter relationships with the illusion that people are normal,
we resist the truth that they are not. We enter an endless attempt
to fix them, control them, or pretend that they are what they're not.
One of the great marks of maturity is to accept the fact that everybody
comes "as is."
Dietrich Bonhoeffer said people enter relationships with their own
particular ideals and dreams of what community should look like. He
wrote surprising words:
But God's grace quickly frustrates all such dreams. A great disillusionment
with others, with Christians in general, and, if we
are fortunate, with ourselves, is bound to overwhelm us as
surely as God desires to lead us to an understanding of genuine
Christian community.... The sooner this moment of disillusionment
comes over the individual and the community, the
better for both.... Those who love their dream of a Christian
community more than the Christian community itself become
destroyers of that Christian community even though their personal
intentions may be ever so honest, earnest, and sacrificial.